15 Must-Have Ingredients for Holiday Food Crafts to Make This Season Deliciously Magical
This post contains affiliate links. I only recommend products I use and love. Read the full disclosure here
Holiday food crafts are one of my favorite ways to make the season feel extra special, and having the right ingredients on hand is absolutely essential. Whether you’re decorating Christmas cookies, jazzing up Hanukkah treats, or whipping up festive goodies for New Year’s, these pantry staples will make your creations both fun and delicious. Trust me, with the right supplies, you can easily turn ordinary recipes into eye-catching, edible works of art!
Let me walk you through my go-to list of must-have ingredients for holiday food crafts. From vibrant sprinkles to the perfect butter, these essentials will have you ready to bake, decorate, and dazzle your loved ones this season.
Edible Glitter
I can’t resist a little sparkle during the holidays! Edible glitter is an absolute game-changer for adding a festive touch to just about anything. I love sprinkling gold or silver glitter on New Year’s cupcakes, dusting blue and white glitter on Hanukkah cookies, and of course, using red and green glitter to bring Christmas treats to life. It’s the quickest way to make your goodies look professional and magical with almost no effort.
Food Coloring and Gel Colors
The brighter, the better—at least when it comes to holiday food crafts! Gel colors are my secret weapon for achieving bold, vibrant hues without watering down frostings or dough. I stick with classic red and green for Christmas, blue and white for Hanukkah, and metallics like gold or silver for a sophisticated New Year’s vibe. They’re perfect for icing cookies, tinting cake batter, or even coloring white chocolate for dipping!
Sprinkles and Sugar Pearls
Sprinkles are like the confetti of the baking world—they instantly make everything more festive! I keep a stash of all colors, but tend to use red and green sprinkles for Christmas, blue and silver mixes for Hanukkah, and elegant gold and white sprinkles for New Year’s.
Sugar pearls are my go-to when I want a touch of elegance on cookies or cupcakes. Pro tip: mix different sprinkle types for a custom holiday look that’s uniquely yours.
Flour
You can’t do much holiday baking without flour! It’s the backbone of cookies, cakes, and pie crusts. I always keep a big bag of all-purpose flour stocked for everything from sugar cookies to gingerbread house walls. It’s one of those ingredients you never want to run out of mid-recipe!
Butter
Is there anything butter can’t make better? For holiday food crafts, I always have salted and unsalted butter on hand. It adds richness to cookies, makes frostings silky smooth, and works wonders for brushing over bread rolls to give them that golden, glossy finish. Plus, melted butter is a lifesaver for binding crumbs in pie crusts or topping desserts.
White and Brown Sugar
These two sugars are a dynamic duo in my kitchen. White sugar is perfect for sweetening cookies, glazes, and frostings, while brown sugar adds a warm, molasses-like flavor to holiday classics like gingerbread cookies. Keep both handy, and you’re ready to tackle almost any recipe.
Leavening Agents (Baking Powder and Baking Soda)
These unsung heroes are what make your cookies light and your cakes fluffy. I double-check my baking soda and powder supply before the holidays because nothing ruins a recipe faster than realizing you’re out of these essentials mid-project.
Baking Chocolate
Chocolate makes everything better, especially during the holidays! Whether it’s drizzled over cookies, melted into brownies, or molded into festive shapes, baking chocolate is a must-have. I like to keep dark, semi-sweet, and white chocolate on hand for a variety of projects.
Yeast
For those holiday breads and rolls that are worth every second of effort, yeast is a must. I love making homemade cinnamon rolls, braided challah, or even shaping bread into festive designs like Christmas trees or wreaths. Yeast brings your creations to life with that pillowy, soft texture.
Powdered Sugar
Whether it’s for dusting cookies, making royal icing, or whipping up a glaze, powdered sugar is one of my must-have ingredients for holiday food crafts I always keep in stock. A light sprinkle on finished treats like Christmas Tree Cookies treats adds a “snowy” touch that’s perfect for the season.
Flavor Extracts
Want to instantly make your treats taste festive? Vanilla extract is a classic, but I like to mix it up with peppermint, almond, or even cinnamon extracts during the holidays. Just a drop or two can take cookies, cupcakes, or frosting to the next level.
Marshmallows (Mini and Regular)
From edible snowmen to hot cocoa toppers, marshmallows are one of the most versatile holiday ingredients. Mini marshmallows are perfect for cocoa bars or snack mixes, while regular ones are great for decorations and gingerbread houses.
Candy Canes and Crushed Peppermints
Candy canes are my go-to for a festive touch. Use whole ones for decorations or to top off cookies, cakes, and cupcakes. The minty sweetness pairs perfectly with chocolatey desserts and gives everything a holiday vibe.
Crushed peppermint also works beautifully as a topping for chocolate peppermint brownies, hot cocoa or as an accent for chocolate-dipped treats. The sweet, minty flavor is the perfect complement to holiday desserts, and they look so pretty, too!
Cocoa Powder
For warm, cozy treats, you can’t beat cocoa powder. It’s great for brownies, chocolate glazes, or even a dusting on whipped cream for hot cocoa. I also use it in frostings for a rich, chocolatey flavor.
Heavy Cream
Whipped cream, ganache, or silky frostings—heavy cream is essential for making desserts extra decadent. During the holidays, I always keep a carton on hand for last-minute crafting and baking.
Royal Icing Mix or Ingredients
Royal icing is a must for decorating cookies or creating gingerbread house masterpieces. I love how easy it is to work with, whether I’m piping intricate details or sticking candies together. Make it from scratch or save time by buying a royal icing mix.
Decorative Candies
Mini candies, candy eyes, and colorful chocolates are my secret weapon for turning treats into edible masterpieces. From reindeer cookies to festive cupcakes, these little extras make your creations pop!
Let’s Make Holiday Magic with these Must-Have Ingredients for Holiday Food Crafts
With these must-have ingredients for holiday food crafts stocked in your pantry, you’re ready to create festive, show-stopping treats for any celebration. What are your go-to ingredients for holiday baking and crafting? Let me know in the comments or tag me on Instagram @funfoodcrafts—I’d love to see what you’re making this season!
Make sure to save this post and share it with your holiday-loving friends. Let’s spread some cheer, one sweet creation at a time!
